Debt
Home Equity Loan To Pay Off Debt?
One of the most common questions I am asked is:
"Should I get a home equity loan to pay off all of my non-house debt?"
Here is my response.
I am not a big fan of consolidating one's non-house debt into a home equity loan. This is for several reasons, and I have outlined those reasons below.
- This is addressing a symptom, not the root cause. This question is usually motivated by our need for immediate action. It is the same motivation that causes us to purchase a car and finance it for five years.
- Borrowing from home equity makes it more difficult to sell the house. This is especially true in today's house market. There are a ton of people who now owe more on their house than it can be sold for. Consequently, they become trapped in the house.
- Changing spending behavior is a process. If one runs out and consolidates their debts, it might remove the urgency from the need to change spending behavior. Changing one's spending behavior takes time. I am convinced that if I had obtained a home equity debt consolidation loan in December 2002, I would not have changed my spending behavior. However, because it took fourteen months to address our debt, our spending behavior was completely changed. We have never looked back!
Having spoken with thousands of people and working one-on-one with nearly one thousand people in the past two years, I am convinced that obtaining a home equity loan is not the best way to eliminate debt. The most common result from obtaining a home equity loan is less equity in the house and the consumer debt shows back up because the spending behavior was not changed.
This is, in fact, my own story. I obtained a debt consolidation loan to move a pile of credit card and consumer debt to one payment. After paying $315.60 a month for an eternity, I wanted to celebrate, but I could not. Why? Because while I had finally paid off the debt consolidation loan, I had not changed my spending behavior and my credit card debt had grown back to more than I had consolidated in the first place!
What do you think?
Related Tools/Articles
Pay Off Debt – Part 05
In this series of posts, I am hoping to equip your family to become debt-free! Jenn and I became debt-free in just 14 months by following this process, and our lives will NEVER be the same! We have been freed up to pursue exactly what we were put on this earth to do – regardless of the income potential!
Previous Steps:
Step 1 – Understand WHY you want to become debt-free! You greatly improve your chances of becoming debt-free when you understand the reasons that you are making sacrifices in lifestyle!
Step 2 – List your debts If you don't know how large the giant is, it makes it really difficult to understand the overall situation!
Step 3 – Calculate your Debt Freedom Date When you have put together your Debt Freedom Date calculation, print it out! Put it on the refrigerator! As you pay off each debt, draw a big line through it! You will not believe the conversation this will start with your family and friends as they come over to visit (you won't be able to afford to go out to each near as much!)
Step 4 – Establish Accountability If married, hold each other accountable. If unmarried, have someone who has won with their own money and has your best interest in mind.
Step 5 – Secure Your Debt Freedom – Save at least $1,000 before attacking your debt!
I have seen so many people calculate their Debt Freedom Date and get all fired up about attacking their debt. They sell everything and everyone in sight. They can't shut up about getting out of debt. It is all they talk about with their spouse. They have even sold their Clay Aiken AND Celine Dion albums!
Everything goes great for two months. They smile every time I see them. "This is awesome", they tell me enthusiastically.
Five months later, they avoid me. When I ask them what is up, they say something like, "Well, Johnny broke his arm and the emergency room bill and doctor bills cost me $1,500. I had no savings so now I am right back where I was – falling back into more debt."
How demoralizing is it to attack debt so fervently and then have to go right back into debt? It is AWFUL! Don't do that! Instead, save up at least $1,000 into an emergency fund before attacking your debt and THEN you can attack your debt all you want!
What happens if you have an emergency pop up while you are attacking your debt? You can use the emergency fund to cover the expense. To replenish the emergency fund, slow down on the debt pay-off plan until you have the $1,000 back in the emergency fund!
By the way, if you have a house, kids, or more than one car I highly recommend $2,500 for your emergency fund.
Secure your debt freedom plan with your emergency fund!
Congratulations! You now know the process that Jenn and I used to become (and stay!) debt-free! You are now equipped!
Question of the Day: What are you going to do now that you are equipped to become debt-free?
Pay Off Debt – Part 04
In this series of posts, I am sharing the process that Jenn and I followed to become debt free in 14 months. You too can become debt-free! Read on!
Here are the steps that have been shared so far:
Step 1 – Understand WHY you want to become debt-free! If you aim at nothing, you will hit it every single time! You are much more likely to become debt-free when you KNOW the reasons you are making the sacrifices!
Step 2 – List your debts You can't slay the dragon until you have faced the dragon and understand how many heads it has!
Step 3 – Calculate your Debt Freedom Date This number lets you know when you will actually achieve debt freedom! Most people can become debt-free (except for the house) in 18 to 36 months!
Step 4 – Establish Accountability
The strongest amongst us can still fall to temptation! You could be making fantastic progress toward debt-freedom and then a new truck pulling a new boat passes you on the road. If you are not careful, you will also be pulling a new truck and boat down the road!
There are two key ways to ensure you are held accountable to your goal of debt-freedom!
A. If married, work together with your spouse. If unmarried, have someone you trust (someone who has won with their money) hold you accountable!
There is incredible power when you work together with your spouse toward debt-freedom! It is a common goal that will unify your marriage and cements your commitment to managing your resources together.
I have also found that when I have a bad case of the "I Wants" and "I Gotta-Have", Jenn does not. She shuts me down! Then, when Jenn gets a bad case of "I Really Want This", I do not. I shut her down! Why? Because we are not doing debt! We are THROUGH with it!!!
B. Plan your spending every single month!
Planned money goes farther than unplanned money! Every single month, Jenn and I sit down TOGETHER and spend every single dollar on paper before we are paid. Don't miss that – that was good! Every. Dollar. On. Paper. BEFORE. We. Are. Paid.
From the day that Jenn and I started budgeting, we have not incurred any new debt. In fact, we became debt-free (minus the house) in just 14 months!
I can tell you this. I HATED the idea of budgeting and now all I do is yell from the mountaintops about how important it is and how EZ it is to budget! There are FREE budget forms that are available HERE. Use one of them to start your journey to debt freedom!
Your budget will hold you accountable. I wouldn't be surprised if it helped you free up $200 – $500 per month to attack your debt even harder (it did for me!).
Question of the Day: Folks who have already become debt-free. How did accountability help you stick to your Debt Freedom Plan?
Do you live near Anderson, SC? Sign up for the Financial Freedom Class at NewSpring Church – class begins on Wednesday, September 19 and costs only $20 per household – childcare provided! You can sign up and pay on-line HERE.
Looking for additional Personal Finance Resources? You can obtain free tools by clicking HERE and purchase books/materials by clicking HERE.
Pay Off Debt – Part 03
In this series of posts, I am sharing the process that Jenn and I used to become debt-free in 14 months. I want you to become debt-free! When you are debt-free, you are freed up to go do exactly what you have been put on earth to do – regardless of the income potential. You can do this!
Let's review the steps so far:
Step 1 – Understand WHY you want to become debt-free! People who have a plan outperform those without a plan. When you clearly understand WHY you are doing this, you are much more likely to make the sacrifices necessary to achieve debt freedom. Hopefully, you have LISTED the hopes/dreams/plans you have for your life.
Step 2 – List your debts If you do not know who you owe and how much you owe them, it becomes very difficult to put together a winning plan! You can print out a debt list sheet HERE.
Step 3 – Calculate your Debt Freedom Date
It is really very simple to calculate your Debt Freedom Date. You need two numbers to calculate your Debt Freedom Date – Total Debt Owed and Total Monthly Payments. I pretend that there is actually only one debt – with one big balance and one big monthly payment.
Look at the sample debt list below. This family will be debt-free in just 33 months!
In the TOOLS section, there is a free tool called the Debt Freedom Date Calculator. If you enter your debts and monthly payments into this tool, it will calculate your Debt Freedom Date for you! If you don't have Microsoft Excel, click HERE for a web-friendly version.
Question of the Day: How many months until you are debt-free?
Do you live near Anderson, SC? Sign up for the Financial Freedom Class at NewSpring Church – class begins on Wednesday, September 19 and costs only $20 per household – childcare provided! You can sign up and pay on-line HERE.
Looking for additional Personal Finance Resources? You can obtain free tools by clicking HERE and purchase books/materials by clicking HERE.
Pay Off Debt – Part 02
In this series of posts, I want to equip you to become debt-free! Jenn and I became debt-free in 14 months by following this process, and I can tell you this – there is NOTHING like living life without the trappings of debt!
Let's review the first step.
Step 1 – Understand WHY you want to be debt-free! If you don't have a clear understanding of why you want to become debt-free, you will have a very tough time sticking to this effort. When you know WHY, you are able to stand firm against the temptation to acquire more debt.
I hope that you have taken the time to write out your hopes/plans/dreams for your life. Again, I cannot overstate the importance of writing this out on paper!
Step 2 – List your debts
During financial counseling sessions, it is a guarantee for any person who has debt that I will calculate their debt freedom date. You should see people's reactions as I put together a list of their debt! Their reactions relay to me the true facts of debt. Here are some very common reactions that I see/hear.
- Hiding their eyes
- "Oh no!"
- "I've never added it up."
- "This is scary."
- Moving to a defensive position as if to guard themselves against the debt
- Turn their head so they don't have to look at the debt total
I KNOW that it can be scary to total up debt. The mere fact that it is so scary tells me two things:
1. People do not like debt.
2. People have not been paying attention to their finances and do not have a well-defined plan for their life. Otherwise, they would not have incurred most of the debt. It is literally ROBBING them of their financial future!
Here is what I say to them – "If you don't know how many heads the dragon has or how large the dragon is, how can you effectively defeat it?"
It is time to slay the dragon. Use THIS FORM to prepare a well-organized list of your debt.
Question of the Day: Why is it so scary to total up debt?
Do you live near Anderson, SC? Sign up for the Financial Freedom Class at NewSpring Church – class begins on Wednesday, September 19 and costs only $20 per household – childcare provided! You can sign up and pay on-line HERE.
Have you subscribed to www.JOESANGL.com? It is easy to do so. Just click HERE!
Looking for additional Personal Finance Resources? You can obtain free tools by clicking HERE and purchase books/materials by clicking HERE.